Case study · Transit agency · Digital Transformation

Charting a technology path for a transit agency.

A structured, fact-based PMIS evaluation that turned a fragmented capital program into a clear modernization roadmap — in three months.

Bus rapid transit corridor at dusk
3
Month evaluation timeline
14
Platforms evaluated
32
Stakeholders across 10 groups
220
Requirements documented
15
Hours of demos facilitated
The challenge

Growing fast, delivering on yesterday's tools.

Rapid growth was placing new demands on the agency's capital delivery organization — and its systems weren't keeping up.

The agency had limited experience leveraging digital tools across capital delivery, and lacked the internal resources needed to navigate the technology landscape, develop an implementation strategy, coordinate vendors, and build organizational alignment. Leadership understood that a significant investment was needed — but they needed a clear place to start.

The approach

Five phases, one fact base.

From discovery to a defensible recommendation, every step of the evaluation was built on evidence the agency's leadership could stand behind.

01

Discovery & current-state assessment

Facilitated a series of workshops with stakeholder groups to establish a shared vision for the future state, document current business processes, and assess existing systems and operational practices. Through workflow mapping, system utilization analysis, and stakeholder interviews, the team identified inefficiencies, pain points, risks, and opportunities for improvement.

02

Requirements gathering

Conducted a structured requirements discovery process with stakeholders across business and technical functions to identify current challenges, future needs, and key success criteria. The 220 validated requirements were prioritized and organized by domain into a comprehensive catalog that became the foundation of the RFP package and the scoring framework for vendor demonstrations — ensuring a transparent, business-driven evaluation.

03

Market scan, vendor demos & peer reference calls

Conducted a comprehensive market assessment of PMIS solutions, screening 14 platforms down to a shortlist of 6 against mandatory and optional requirements. Each shortlisted vendor participated in a standardized demonstration built on detailed business scenarios, enabling objective, side-by-side comparison. Reference interviews with peer public-sector agencies surfaced deployment experiences, adoption challenges, risks, best practices, and realized benefits — a fact base for vendor selection.

04

Cost, benefit & risk analysis

Developed a 10-year Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) model and a weighted SWOT scorecard for each candidate solution. The analysis quantified all major cost components, evaluated risks and opportunities, and documented mitigation strategies — enabling leadership to confidently select the vendor best aligned with the organization's financial and strategic objectives.

05

Recommendation & roadmap

Delivered a comprehensive feasibility study and executive briefing that translated findings into actionable recommendations, a phased implementation roadmap, and a clear decision framework — enabling leadership to confidently move the initiative forward.

The evaluation framework

From 220 requirements to a weighted scorecard.

To move the evaluation from opinion to evidence, InnoActive Group developed a weighted criteria framework spanning four categories. Every criterion traced back to the validated requirements catalog, and each shortlisted vendor was scored against the same standard — giving leadership a transparent, side-by-side view and a defensible basis for the final recommendation.

01 — Functional fit

Does it do the work?

Core project management capabilities, portfolio-level visibility and reporting, and configurable workflow and governance — measured against the agency's validated requirements.

02 — Technical & integration

Does it fit the landscape?

Fit with the agency's systems landscape, IT and security standards, scalability, and the effort required to support the platform over time.

03 — Public-sector readiness

Has it worked for peers?

Documented transit and public-sector deployments of comparable capital program scale, validated through peer-agency reference interviews.

04 — Commercial & implementation

What will it really cost?

Total cost of ownership, vendor viability, procurement options, and the complexity of implementation, training, and phased rollout.

100%

Each category carries a defined weight, and every shortlisted vendor was scored against the same standard — producing a transparent, weighted result that leadership could defend to the board.

The outcome

A clear place to start — and finish.

The agency emerged from the engagement with a clear modernization strategy and a practical roadmap for the PMIS evaluation, procurement, and implementation.

Leadership gained a structured decision-making framework connecting technology investment to business objectives, operational needs, and long-term capital program goals — with the confidence to move the initiative forward.

About InnoActive Group

InnoActive Group is a consulting firm for owners of large capital programs. We bring deep project delivery experience together with modern technology and the speed of a startup, so owners get clear, reliable reporting on cost, schedule and risk — and the tools to act on it.

Top 17% on the Inc. 5000 list — among the fastest-growing private companies in the nation. We have a saying: every single client remains a client and/or a reference.

01Project Management
02Project Controls
03Data Intelligence
04Digital Transformation
05Artificial Intelligence

Ready to chart your
technology path?

Get in touch →